Keywords
magâzî
Islamic historiography
military history of Islam
Judeo-Christian and Muslim tradition
How to Cite
-
Abstract730
-
PDF (Español)590
-
XML (Español)612
Abstract
This paper is a critical review of the recent book by Roberto Marín Guzmán and Manuel Enrique López Brenes, La batalla de Hunayn y las interrogantes que suscita. Reflexiones en torno al problema de la tradición musulmana y las fuentes árabes (The Battle of Hunayn and the questions it raises. Reflections on the problem of Muslim tradition and Arab sources). The authors offer a re-thinking of this episode, analyzing the primary sources for the historical account, consisting of testimonies full with contradictions and apparent inaccuracies, which, however, being linked to the life of the Prophet of Islam, are not easy to question. The paper argues for the relevance of Marín Guzmán and López Brenes’ contribution, a much-needed analytical perspective that allows a more accurate view of the history of classical Islam, above and beyond Muslim dogma
References
BRUHL, Fr., "Muḥammad" en M.Th. Houtsma, et al., (eds.), E.J. Brill's First Encyclopaedia of Islam 1913-1936, 9 vols., Leiden, E.J. Brill, 1993, vol. VI, pp. 641-657.
CAETANI, Leone, (comp.), Annali dell'Islam, 10 v., Hildesheim, Georg Olms Verlag, 1972.
CHELHOD, Joseph Les structures du sacré chez les arabes, Paris, Editions Maisonneuve et Larose, 1986.
LOS CUARENTA HADICES. Nawawiyah, Riyadh, International Islamic Federation of Student Organizations, 1992.
DAWANI, ءAlî , "ءAlî junto al Profeta (BP)", El mensaje de Az-Zaqalain, año 6, núm. 19, junio 2001, pp. 96-104.
DECONICK, April, Holy Misogyny. Why the Sex and Gender Conflicts in the Early Church Still Matter, Nueva York, Continuum, 2011.
DECONICK, April, “How the Mother God Got Sprayed?”, Biblical Archaeology Review, vol. XXXVIII, núm. 5, septiembre-octubre 2012, pp. 2, 63.
ERNST, Carl W., Following Muhammad. Rethinking Islam in the Contemporary World, Chapel Hill, The University of North Carolina Press, 2003.
FINKELSTEIN, Israel y N. Asher Silberman, The Bible Unearthed. Archaeology’s New Vision of Ancient Israel and the Origin of Its Sacred Texts, Nueva York, The Free Press, 2001.
GARFINKEL, Yosef, “The Birth and Death of Biblical Minimalism”, Biblical Archaeology Review, Washington, D.C., vol. XXXVII, núm. 3, mayo-junio 2011, pp. 46-53.
GAUDEFROY-DEMOMBYNES, Maurice, Mahoma, pról. por Paul Chalus, trad. por J. López Pérez, México, UTEHA, 1960.
Al-GAZZÂLÎ, The remembrance of death and the afterlife. Kitâb dhikr al-mawt wa-mâ baءdahu, Book XL of The revival of the religious sciences IHyâ ءulûm al-dîn, intr., nots y trad. por T.J. Einter, Cambridge, The Islamic Texts Society, 1989.
HUSSEIN, Mahmoud, Les musulmans au défi de Daech, Paris, Gallimard, 2016.
IBN JALDÚN, Introducción a la historia universal (Al-Muqaddimah), prefacio y est. prel. por Elías Trabulse, trad. de Juan Feres, México, Fondo de Cultura Económica, 1977.
IBN JALDÚN, Introducción a la historia universal (Al-Muqaddimah), ed. y trad. de Francisco Ruiz Girela, bibliografía seleccionada por Miguel Ángel Manzano, glosarios preparados por Irene Bernabé Blanco, Córdoba, Almuzara-Biblioteca de Literatura Universal, 2008.
IBN KATHÎR, The Life of the Prophet MuHammad, 4 v., trad. por Trevor Le Gassick, rev. por Muneer Fareed, Doha-Reading, The Center for Muslim Contribution to Civilization-Garnet, 2000.
Muḥammad ibn ءAbd Allâh AL-KISA’I [c. 1200,]
Tales of the Prophets (Qiṣaṣ al-anbiyâ’), trad. por W. Thackston, Chicago, Great Books of the Islamic World, 1997.
KNAPPERT, Jan, Islamic legends. Histories of the heroes, saints and prophets of Islam, 2 vols., Leiden, E.J. Brill, 1985.
LIVERANI, Mario, El antiguo oriente. Historia, sociedad y economía, rev. por Joaquín Córdoba, trad. por J. Vivanco, Barcelona, Crítica, 1995.
LIVERANI, Mario, Oltre la Bibbia. Storia antica di Israele, 4ª. ed., Roma, Laterza, 2005.
MAÍLLO SALGADO, Felipe, “La construcción de la historia desde el Islam”, Anales de Historia Antigua, Medieval y Moderna, vol. XLI, 2009, pp. 1-35.
MAÍLLO SALGADO, Felipe, De Historiografía árabe, Madrid, Abada Editores, 2008.
MAÍLLO SALGADO, Felipe, Vocabulario básico de historia del Islam, Madrid, Akal, 1987.
MACDONALD, John, "The creation of man and angels in the eschatological literature", Islamic Studies, vol. III, núm. 3, septiembre 1964, pp. 285-308.
MORGAN, David, “The Evolution of Two Asian Historiographical Traditions”, Michael Bentley, (ed.), Companion to Historiography, Nueva York, Routledge, 1997, pp. 11-22.
PAREJA, Félix María , et al., Islamología, 2 vols., Madrid, Razón y Fe, 1952-1954.
RUIZ FIGUEROA, Manuel, La religión islámica: una introducción, México, Centro de Estudios de Asia y África. El Colegio de México, 2002.
SAND, Shlomo, La invención del pueblo judío, trad. por. J.M. Amoroto, Madrid, Akal, 2011.
SCHACHT, Joseph, «A revaluation of Islamic traditions», The Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society of Great Britain and Ireland, ptes. 3 y 4, 1949, pp. 143-154.
STETKEVYCH, Jaroslav, Muḥamamad and the Golden Bough. Reconstructing Arabian Myth, Bloomington, Indiana University Press, 1996.
Abû-Ga'far Muḥammad ibn Garîr AL-ŢABARÎ, Chronique de al-Ţabarî, 4 vols., ed. de Hermann Zotenberg, Paris, Librairie G.P. Maisonneuve-Editions Besson et Chantemerle, 1958.
Walî al-Dîn MuHammad ibn ءAbdallâh al-Jaţîb AL-TIBRÎZÎ, [d. en 1337,] Mishkat al-Masabih, [Miškât al-maşabiH, Niche for Lamps] 2 v., trad. al inglés y notas explicativas por James Robson, Lahore, Muhammad Ashraf, 1960.
TRITTON, A.S., "Djanâza" en A. Abel, et al., (eds.), Encyclopédie de l'Islam nouvelle édition, 12 vols., Leiden-Paris, E.J. Brill- G.P. Maisonneuve, 1954-2005, vol. II, pp. 453-454.
YOUNG, M.J.L., "The Treatment of the Principle of Evil in the Qur'ân", Islamic Studies, vol. V, núm. 3, septiembre 1966, pp. 275-281.
WILLIAMS, Rebecca Ruth, “An Analysis of the Supernatural Archetype of the Prophet Muḥammad as Found in the Sîra/Ta’rîkh and Tafsîr Works of Al-Ţabarî and Ibn Kathîr”, tesis de Doctorado en Filosofía, Institute of Islamic Studies. McGill University, Montreal, 2006.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License
Copyright 2022 Estudios de Asia y África